Adele’s holiday photos show her dramatic weight loss and spark debate about body image.

Adele set fire to the internet this week when she took to Instagram to share photos from her Christmas party in which she is posing with a Grinch and a guy in a Santa suit (who may or may not be Santa, who’s to say?!). And it wasn’t the Grinch or Santa that got people in their feelings. It was the 31-year-old singer’s svelte figure.

Advertisements

Many commenters are calling Adele “unrecognizable” in the photos, alluding to her significant weight loss. The media, and many of her fans, are praising the singer’s “transformation.”

β€œLet the pie fall,
When it crumbles,
We will stand tall,
Face it all together.” πŸ₯§

FABULOUS. Incredible weightloss by #Adele. Unrecognisable. V Jerry Hall 🌟#Piefall pic.twitter.com/K232XctrwI

β€” India Willoughby (@IndiaWilloughby) December 24, 2019

But Twitter user Audra Williams shared a thread, which has gone viral, explaining why celebrating Adele’s weight loss is a “garbage thing to do.”

Celebrating Adele’s weight loss is a garbage thing to do for a million reasons. Here are two:

1. It tells your fat friends you think their bodies are a problem to be solved.

2. The weight loss could be the result of physical or mental health struggles. Weird to cheer about!

β€” Audra Williams (@audrawilliams) December 24, 2019

She writes:

Celebrating Adele’s weight loss is a garbage thing to do for a million reasons. Here are two: 1. It tells your fat friends you think their bodies are a problem to be solved. 2. The weight loss could be the result of physical or mental health struggles. Weird to cheer about!

Williams shared her own story about how a nervous breakdown left her “unable to eat,” and that her extreme weight loss at the time was neither healthy nor an “achievement.”

screen shot 2019 12 26 at 110753 am zmdQg1
screen shot 2019 12 26 at 110800 am WBYMiK
screen shot 2019 12 26 at 110805 am

She explains that we have “no idea how/why Adele lost weight,” and that by celebrating her physical transformation, we could unknowingly be applauding an illness or an eating disorder.

screen shot 2019 12 26 at 110811 am R0Mrp8

She points out that you can’t assess someone’s health by looking at them.

screen shot 2019 12 26 at 110817 am 65TnIW

She continues that she’s not criticizing Adele’s size or Adele in general; she’s criticizing the people commenting on and celebrating the visual changes in her body.

screen shot 2019 12 26 at 110823 am Q1Fpm7
screen shot 2019 12 26 at 110829 am HJIqNH

The subject of weight loss and body positivity, as it so often does, has ignited an emotional controversy. Many people are insisting that thinner = healthier, and sharing their own weight loss stories.

My wife and I just had a baby girl and my primary care provider advised me to make healthier choices or else I might not live long. Out of love for my family and life I did. I lost 60 lbs. I feel great and healthier… and I love compliments

β€” Sal Fatano (@LoveTruth55555) December 24, 2019

Not everything is about you, Audra.

I’m going to continue losing weight and encouraging those around me to get healthy as well.

Adele looks fantastic, happy, and confident and I’m so happy for her. ☺️

β€” Freckled Liberty πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡Έ (@FreckledLiberty) December 24, 2019

But people can celebrate it if they want too. And your journey & her journey maybe different. It is like saying we can’t celebrate weddings cos it may upset your divorced friends πŸ™„πŸ™ˆ Adele looks amazing now & did before. I personally fluctuate in weight all the time so what.

β€” Kurtis-Lee Lewis (@KurtisLeeSinger) December 25, 2019

Being overweight is a problem that can be solved.

β€” David Vainqueur (@True_Canuck1) December 24, 2019

But despite all those things is it not better to be healthy and to celebrate good health? This is like good cheer gate keeping.

β€” Fred Faust (@thefredelement) December 24, 2019

People are shaming Williams for shaming people for fat-shaming.

Yea, and neither do you. Maybe what you’re saying is the complete opposite. Maybe you shaming this situation is shaming all those who bust their ass to get in shape and are proud. It’s unfortunate you went through what you did, but projecting that on others is ridiculous.

β€” Eric Caruso (@ericcaruso77) December 24, 2019

But Williams continues to point out the problem with assuming that Adele was unhealthy before and is healthier now.

You know exactly nothing about Adele’s health or thought process or desires for her own body. And losing weight only boosts confidence because our world denigrates fat bodies.

β€” Audra Williams (@audrawilliams) December 24, 2019

Celebrating weight loss is not celebrating health.

β€” Audra Williams (@audrawilliams) December 24, 2019

A few people have pointed to this earlier Instagram from Adele in which she seems to suggest that she’s been working out, writing “I used to cry but now I sweat.”

Really good thread, but in this case I think she’s made it clear that she has lost weight from working out more (unless sweating means something else idk). It still is weird to me that it is “newsworthy” that a gorgeous talented woman lost weight thoughhttps://t.co/EOLLGwJE4j

β€” SinnieπŸŒ™ (@Sinnie_Moon) December 24, 2019

She literally commented on her insta that she’s been “sweating it out”, e.g. working out.

β€” Nay (@nay_sue1) December 24, 2019

Adele said she did circuit training, cardio, and Pilates. You can hardly unintentionally do pilates.

It’s been reported she goes to Ayda Field’s class.

Then in an instagram post she put “I used to cry but now I sweat”

Clearly, it is HER intention. Let her have her autonomy.

β€” Milky Handshake (@ifeastonglue) December 25, 2019

But Williams responded that exercise doesn’t necessarily equate with weight loss.

Thank you for this thoughtful response! I guess I know so many fat people who also exercise that I don’t equate someone talking about working out as being about weight loss.

β€” Audra Williams (@audrawilliams) December 24, 2019

Like so many controversial subjects, this debate seems to center around people projecting based on their own experiences.

Some people work really hard to lose weight, putting in a lot of time, dedication & effort. If you’ve had a rough time that sucks, but projecting your negative experience onto her is also not fair. She looks very happy. People need to stop looking for their self worth in others.

β€” Nat (@Nat__Cat) December 24, 2019

some people put a lot of time and effort trying to feel ok about the way they are, in a society that is full of images that make them feel bad about who they are

β€” Condolent Cheer β’Ά (@nailsfromthesky) December 24, 2019

This is a tricky issueβ€”as someone who has overcome an eating disorder, I recognize the important of Williams’ point and am inclined to agree with her. But I also recognize that for many people, losing weight is associated with increased health and happiness, and in those cases it is something to be celebrated.

But I think we can all agree on one thing: we just want Adele to be happy. But not so happy that she stops producing devastating breakup songs to help us get over all of our exes.

This content was originally published here.

You May Also Like